JOINT COMPLIANCE AND INSPECTION COMMISSION
AGREEMENT NUMBER 24
RELATING TO THE TREATY BETWEEN
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND
THE UNION OF SOVIET SOCIALIST REPUBLICS ON
THE REDUCTION AND LIMITATION OF STRATEGIC OFFENSIVE ARMS
OF JULY 31, 1991
PROCEDURES FOR THE USE OF RADIATION DETECTION EQUIPMENT
AT WEAPONS STORAGE AREAS
The Government of the United States of America, the Government of
the Republic of Belarus, the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan,
the Government of the Russian Federation, and the Government of Ukraine,
hereinafter referred to as the Parties,
In accordance with the Treaty between the United States of America
and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics on the Reduction and Limitation
of Strategic Offensive Arms of July 31, 1991, hereinafter referred to
as the Treaty,
To improve the viability and effectiveness of the Protocol on Inspections
and Continuous Monitoring Activities Relating to the Treaty, hereinafter
referred to as the Inspection Protocol,
Have agreed as follows:
Article One
1. Subparagraph 4(c) of Subsection A of Section I of Annex 8 to the
Inspection Protocol shall be superseded by the following provisions:
"(c) Set of radiation detection equipment consisting of the following:
(i) 2 Neutron detectors, Sandia National Laboratory design, He-3-based,
polyethylene-moderated, including preamplifiers with signal/power
cables, counting time - 150 seconds;
(ii) 2 Electronic counters, Eberline, Model ESP-2 modified, with
instruction manual;
(iii) 10 Plastic bags for weather protection;
(iv) 1 Americium-241-Lithium neutron source for calibration, emitting
approximately 3000 neutrons per second, precalibrated by the inspecting
Party;
(v) 1 Tool kit, Jensen Tools, Model JTK-6;
(vi) 30 Spare batteries, miscellaneous, sizes C and D;
(vii) l Stand for neutron detector;
(viii) l Measuring tape;
(ix) 2 Battery-powered lights, Maglight, Model ML-2;
(x) 3 Programmable calculators, Hewlett-Packard, Model HP-27s,
with instruction manual;
(xi) 2 Thermometers;
(xii) 1 Stand for calibration source; and
(xiii) 4 Operating instruction manuals, two in English and two
in Russian."
2. Subparagraph 4(b) of Subsection B of Section I of Annex 8 to the
Inspection Protocol shall be superseded by the following provisions:
"(b) Set of SRPN 3 or SRPN 6 radiation detection equipment of the Russian
Federation consisting of the following:
(i) 2 Neutron detectors, including preamplifiers with signal/power
cables, manufactured by NIIIT, Model SRPN 3.01.000, counting time
- 1000 seconds, or Model SRPN 6.02.000, counting time - 150 seconds;
(ii) 2 Registering devices, manufactured by NIIIT, Model SRPN
3.03.000 or SRPN 6.01.000;
(iii) 1 Americium-241-Lithium neutron source for calibration,
emitting approximately 3000 neutrons per second, precalibrated by
the inspecting Party;
(iv) 1 Charging unit, manufactured by NIIIT, Model SE-387 or SE-408;
(v) 2 Spare rechargeable batteries, Model 10NKGTs-1D;
(vi) 2 Measuring tapes;
(vii) 2 Battery-powered lights;
(viii) 2 Stands for neutron detectors;
(ix) 2 Calculators, Casio, Model FX-120;
(x) 1 Stand for calibration source; and
(xi) 4 Operating instruction manuals, two in English and two in
Russian."
Article Two
l. Paragraphs 3 and 4 of Subsection F of Section VI of Annex 8 to
the Inspection Protocol shall be superseded by the following provisions:
"3. Before conducting measuring procedures using radiation detection
equipment, inspectors and the in-country escort shall have the right
to confirm the operability of the radiation detection equipment, using
the following procedures:
(a) For radiation detection equipment used pursuant to this paragraph,
the counting time of each individual measurement shall be the counting
time specified in subparagraph 4(c) of Subsection A or subparagraph
4(b) of Subsection B of Section I of this Annex for the neutron detectors
in the sets of radiation detection equipment of the United States
of America or the Russian Federation, respectively.
(b) The operability of each neutron detector in a set of radiation
detection equipment shall be confirmed.
(c) The neutron detector shall be placed in a mutually agreed
location.
(d) The inspecting Party shall take two background measurements
with the calibration source at least three meters from the neutron
detector. If the difference between these two measurements is less
than or equal to 30 percent of their average, the average of these
measurements shall be recorded as the average background value for
the operability check. If the difference between these two background
measurements is greater than 30 percent of their average, a third
background measurement shall be taken. The third background measurement
shall be compared with the previously taken background measurement
that is closest to the third background measurement. If the difference
between the third background measurement and the closest previous
background measurement is less than or equal to 30 percent of the
average of these two measurements, the average of these two measurements
shall be recorded as the average background value for the operability
check. Otherwise, the results of all three background measurements
shall be recorded and the radiation detection equipment shall not
be accepted as operable.
(e) With the neutron detector in the same location used for the
background measurements taken in accordance with subparagraph (c)
of this paragraph, the inspecting Party shall place the calibration
source in contact with the neutron detector at the center of the
detector's sensitive area as indicated by the markings on the neutron
detector.
(f) The inspecting Party shall take two calibration measurements
of the radiation level from the calibration source. The average
of these two calibration measurements shall be recorded as the average
value of the calibration measurement.
(g) The following values shall be calculated:
(i) the calculated calibration value, which is the difference between
the average value of the calibration measurement determined in accordance
with subparagraph (f) of this paragraph and the average background
value determined in accordance with subparagraph (d) of this paragraph;
(ii) the product of the counting time for each measurement and
the equivalent flux of the calibration source, which is a fixed
value indicated on the calibration source; and
(iii) the sensitivity of the neutron detector, which is the
ratio of the values obtained in accordance with subparagraphs
(g)(i) and (g)(ii) of this paragraph.
(h) The radiation detection equipment shall be accepted as operable,
provided:
(i) the difference between the two calibration measurements taken
in accordance with subparagraph (f) of this paragraph is less than
or equal to 30 percent of the average value of the calibration measurement;
and
(ii) the difference between the value of the sensitivity of
the neutron detector, determined in accordance with subparagraph
(g)(iii) of this paragraph, and the laboratory value of the sensitivity
of the neutron detector, as recorded on the neutron detector,
is less than or equal to 15 percent of the average of these two
sensitivity values.
(i) The results of the measurements obtained in accordance with
subparagraphs (d) and (f) of this paragraph shall be recorded either
in the inspection report or in a form, agreed upon by the Parties,
used to record the confirmation of the operability of the radiation
detection equipment at the point of entry.
4. The inspecting Party, prior to beginning to use its radiation
detection equipment during the first inspection conducted with the
use of radiation detection equipment, shall deliver to the inspected
Party, for purchase or examination by the inspected Party, one of
each of the items in the sets of radiation detection equipment specified
in subparagraph 4(c) of Subsection A or subparagraph 4(b) of Subsection
B of Section I of this Annex, for each model, except for the calibration
source. No later than 30 days after the inspected Party has received
such items of radiation detection equipment, the inspected Party shall
inform the inspecting Party whether the inspecting Party is permitted
to use during inspections such radiation detection equipment. Until
permission for the use of such radiation detection equipment is given
by the inspected Party, the inspecting Party shall not bring to a
point of entry on the territory of the inspected Party other radiation
detection equipment."
2. The following provisions shall constitute paragraphs 5, 6, 7 and
8 of Subsection F of Section VI of Annex 8 to the Inspection Protocol:
"5. For points of entry associated with inspection sites at which radiation
detection equipment may be used, the inspecting Party shall bring to
each such point of entry on the territory of the inspected Party for
use during inspections, at times agreed upon with the inspected Party,
no less than one set of radiation detection equipment.
(a) Except as provided for in paragraphs 6 and 7 of this Subsection,
each such set of radiation detection equipment shall be subject to
examination and stored at the point of entry in accordance with the
procedures provided for in this paragraph.
(b) The examination of such sets of radiation detection equipment
shall be completed no later than five days after the date when these
sets of radiation detection equipment are brought to the point of
entry. During the examination of the radiation detection equipment,
the inspected Party shall be permitted, in the presence of the inspecting
Party, to partially disassemble such equipment and examine it using
non-damaging methods. Such examination must not impair the capability
of the radiation detection equipment to perform functions connected
with the inspection requirements under the Treaty. Upon completion
of the examination and prior to departure from the point of entry,
the inspecting Party shall have the right to confirm the operability
of the radiation detection equipment in accordance with paragraph
3 of this Subsection in order to establish that its capability to
perform functions connected with the inspection requirements under
the Treaty has not been impaired as a result of the examination
of such radiation detection equipment by the inspected Party.
(c) Upon completion of the examination, the sets of radiation
detection equipment shall be stored at the point of entry in tamper-proof
containers provided by the inspecting Party, and shall be located
within a secure structure or room in accordance with paragraph 14
of Section V of this Protocol. No more than three sets of radiation
detection equipment shall be stored at each point of entry associated
with inspection sites at which radiation detection equipment may
be used.
(d) The procedures for delivering radiation detection equipment
for examination and storage at points of entry, transportation and
arrangements for the stay of technical experts delivering and supporting
the examination of such equipment on the territory of the inspected
Party, and reimbursement of associated costs shall be subject to
agreement.
6. For an inspection conducted pursuant to paragraph 2, 3 or 4 of
Article XI of the Treaty, an inspection team shall be permitted to
bring to a point of entry calibration sources that are part of the
sets of radiation detection equipment stored at the point of entry,
replacement spare batteries and rechargeable batteries, as well as
an additional set of radiation detection equipment. All such equipment
brought to the point of entry shall be subject to examination in accordance
with paragraph 8 of Section V of this Protocol.
7. For an inspection conducted pursuant to paragraph 2, 3 or 4 of
Article XI of the Treaty, the inspection team, upon arrival at the
point of entry, shall have the right, in the presence of the in-country
escort, to examine the tamper-proof containers in which the radiation
detection equipment is stored and the radiation detection equipment
in such containers. The inspection team shall have the right to select
one set of radiation detection equipment for use during the inspection
from among the sets of such equipment stored at the point of entry
in accordance with subparagraph 5(c) of this Subsection or an additional
set of radiation detection equipment brought to the point of entry
by the inspection team, and to confirm its operability in accordance
with the procedures provided for in paragraph 3 of this Subsection,
for no more than four hours.
(a) If the inspection team determines that the containers for at least
one of the sets of radiation detection equipment have not been tampered
with, and that the set of radiation detection equipment contained
in such containers is operable in accordance with paragraph 3 of this
Subsection, then such a set of radiation detection equipment shall
be used in conducting the inspection.
(b) If either the inspection team or the in-country escort determines
that the containers for all the sets of radiation detection equipment
have been tampered with, the inspection team shall have the right
to use an additional set of radiation detection equipment brought
to the point of entry by the inspection team and examined in accordance
with paragraph 8 of Section V of this Protocol, the operability
of which has been confirmed in accordance with the procedures provided
for in paragraph 3 of this Subsection, in conducting the inspection.
(c) For containers that have not been tampered with, if either
the inspection team or the in-country escort determines that all
the sets of radiation detection equipment stored in such containers
are not operable, the inspection team shall have the right to use
an additional set of radiation detection equipment brought to the
point of entry by the inspection team in conducting the inspection.
In this case, the date and time for the designation of the inspection
site and the type of inspection pursuant to paragraph 4 of Section
III of this Protocol shall be delayed, if necessary, until the in-country
escort has completed its examination of such radiation detection
equipment using the procedures provided for in paragraph 5 of this
Subsection, and the inspection team has confirmed the operability
of such radiation detection equipment in accordance with paragraph
3 of this Subsection. In no case shall such delay exceed 12 hours
or require the inspection team to delay the date and time for the
designation of the inspection site and type of inspection beyond
the time limit specified in paragraph 4 of Section III of this Protocol
for the type of inspection being conducted.
(d) If there are no signs that the containers have been tampered
with and any set of radiation detection equipment stored in such
containers is not operable, the inspecting Party shall return such
a set or sets of radiation detection equipment and associated containers
to the territory of the inspecting Party. The inspecting Party shall
inform the inspected Party of the cause of the malfunction and measures
taken to preclude such malfunctions in the future.
(e) If an additional set of radiation detection equipment is brought
to the point of entry by the inspection team and is not used in
conducting the inspection, such radiation detection equipment shall
be stored at the point of entry in tamper-proof containers and removed
from the territory of the inspected Party by the inspection team
when it leaves the territory of the inspected Party.
(f) In all cases, only one set of radiation detection equipment
whose operability has been confirmed in accordance with the procedures
provided for in paragraph 3 of this Subsection shall be used during
an inspection.
8. For an inspection conducted pursuant to paragraph 4 or 5 of Section
IV of Annex 4 to this Protocol, radiation detection equipment shall
be used in accordance with the following procedures:
(a) The counting time of each individual measurement shall be the
counting time specified in subparagraph 4(c) of Subsection A or subparagraph
4(b) of Subsection B of Section I of this Annex for the neutron detectors
in the sets of radiation detection equipment of the United States
of America or the Russian Federation, respectively.
(b) The inspection team shall have the right to observe the use
of the radiation detection equipment to confirm that the procedures
set forth in this paragraph are followed.
(c) After arrival at the inspection site, prior to conducting
radiation measurements the inspection team shall confirm, in accordance
with the procedures provided for in paragraph 3 of this Subsection,
that at least one neutron detector in the set of radiation detection
equipment is operable. If the inspection team is unable to confirm
the operability of at least one neutron detector, this fact shall
be recorded in the inspection report and the inspection shall proceed
without the use of radiation detection equipment.
(d) Measurements of radiation levels, in accordance with subparagraphs
(f) and (g) of this paragraph, of the object designated by the inspection
team for radiation measurements shall be taken at the location selected
for that purpose by the in-country escort, using a neutron detector
whose operability has been confirmed pursuant to subparagraph (c)
of this paragraph.
(e) Background measurements shall be taken by the in-country escort
no less than ten meters from the object designated by the inspection
team for radiation measurements. Such background measurements shall
be taken in accordance with the following procedures:
(i) The inspection team shall identify to the in-country escort
the front surface of the neutron detector that will be directed
toward the object designated for measurement of the radiation level.
The front surface of the neutron detector shall be positioned vertically,
at approximately the same height at which measurements on the designated
object will be taken.
(ii) Two background measurements shall be taken. The average
of these two measurements shall be calculated and recorded in
the inspection report as the average background value.
(iii) If the average background value is greater than 450 counts,
another location for taking the background measurements shall
be selected by the in-country escort. Background measurements
shall be taken until an average background value is obtained that
is less than 450 counts at a selected location.
(iv) The square root of the average background value shall be
calculated to two decimal places and the result multiplied by
four. This number shall be added to the average background value
and the result shall be rounded up to the higher whole number.
This number shall be recorded in the inspection report as the
comparison number to be used in subparagraph (f) of this paragraph.
(f) For an inspection conducted pursuant to paragraph 4 or subparagraph
5(c) of Section IV of Annex 4 to this Protocol, the following procedures
shall be used:
(i) The inspection team shall select no more than four points along
the length of the ALCM or container at which radiation measurements
will be taken. A description of the ALCM or container shall be recorded
as a diagram in the inspection report. The approximate dimensions
of the ALCM or container, and the approximate location of each measurement
point, shall be indicated on this diagram.
(ii) The in-country escort shall position the neutron detector
in a location specified by the inspection team, no less than seven
centimeters and no greater than two meters from the surface of
the ALCM or container, with a maximum permissible deviation from
these established distances not to exceed 20 percent, so that
the neutron detector is at the same level as the point where the
measurement will be taken, with the front surface of the neutron
detector facing the point on the ALCM or container where the measurement
will be taken.
(iii) The in-country escort shall take two measurements of the
radiation level at each selected point. The average of the two
measurements shall be calculated, and if not a whole number, shall
be rounded up to the higher whole number. This average shall be
recorded in the inspection report as the average measurement at
that point.
(iv) If the average measurement of the radiation level at each
selected point is less than or equal to the comparison number
calculated in accordance with subparagraph (e)(iv) of this paragraph,
the ALCM or container shall not be subject to further inspection.
(v) If the average measurement of the radiation level at any
of the four selected points is greater than the comparison number
calculated in accordance with subparagraph (e)(iv) of this paragraph,
this fact shall be recorded in the inspection report and the ALCM
or container shall be subject to further inspection in accordance
with subparagraph 4(a)(ii) or subparagraph 4(b)(iii) of Section
IV of Annex 4 to this Protocol, as applicable.
(g) To confirm, pursuant to subparagraph 5(c) of Section IV of
Annex 4 to this Protocol, that a container does not conceal the
presence of radiation, the following procedures shall be used:
(i) The inspection team shall select no more than four points on
the container wall at which radiation measurements will be taken
for the purpose of measuring the radiation shielding effect. A description
of the container shall be recorded as a diagram in the inspection
report. The approximate dimensions of the container and the approximate
location of each measurement point shall be indicated on this diagram.
(ii) The in-country escort shall open the container and place
the calibration source on its stand inside the container on the
longitudinal axis of the container. The neutron detector shall
be placed outside the container in a location specified by the
inspection team, no less than seven centimeters and no greater
than two meters from the surface of the container, with a maximum
permissible deviation from established distances not to exceed
20 percent. The calibration source and neutron detector shall
be placed on a horizontal straight line that passes through the
center of the calibration source and the center of the neutron
detector, that lies on a plane perpendicular to the longitudinal
axis of the container, and that intersects the wall of the container
at the selected point on the container. The distance between the
center of the calibration source and the center of the neutron
detector shall be recorded in the inspection report. The front
surface of the neutron detector shall face the selected point.
(iii) The in-country escort shall take two measurements of the
radiation level at each selected point on the container. The container
shall remain closed during measurements of the radiation level.
The average of the two measurements shall be calculated. The average
background value, calculated in accordance with subparagraph (e)(ii)
of this paragraph, shall be subtracted from this average. The
result shall be recorded in the inspection report as the net average
value of radiation obtained when the calibration source is placed
inside the container at that point.
(iv) The procedures provided for in subparagraphs (g)(ii) and
(g)(iii) of this paragraph shall be repeated until measurements
have been taken at all the points on the container selected by
the inspection team, and the results have been recorded in the
inspection report.
(v) The calibration source shall be removed from the container
and the neutron detector repositioned no less than two meters
from the container with its front surface no longer facing the
container.
(vi) The in-country escort shall position the calibration source
in front of the front surface of the neutron detector so that
the distance between the front surface of the neutron detector
and the calibration source is the same distance, within three
percent, as that used for one of the measurements taken pursuant
to subparagraph (g)(iii) of this paragraph. No objects that could
interfere with the flow of neutrons to the neutron detector shall
be located near the calibration source or the neutron detector.
(vii) The in-country escort shall take two measurements of the
radiation level with the calibration source and the neutron detector
positioned in accordance with subparagraphs (g)(v) and (g)(vi)
of this paragraph. The average of the two measurements shall be
calculated. The average background value calculated in accordance
with subparagraph (e)(ii) of this paragraph shall be subtracted
from this average. The result shall be recorded in the inspection
report as the net average value of radiation obtained when the
calibration source is placed outside the container at the distance
used pursuant to subparagraph (g)(vi) of this paragraph.
(viii) The procedures provided for in subparagraphs (g)(vi)
and (g)(vii) of this paragraph shall be repeated for each distance
between the calibration source and the neutron detector used for
the measurements of the radiation level taken pursuant to subparagraph
(g)(iii) of this paragraph.
(ix) For each point on the container, calculations shall be
carried out, in which the net average value of the radiation level
obtained pursuant to subparagraph (g)(iii) when the calibration
source is placed inside the container is divided by the corresponding
net average value of the radiation level obtained pursuant to
subparagraph (g)(vii) when the calibration source is placed outside
the container. The division shall be carried out to two decimal
places. If the result of the division with respect to any point
is less than 0.5, this fact shall be recorded in the inspection
report.
(x) For containers of long-range non-nuclear ALCMs of a type
for which a notification has been provided in accordance with
Section VII of the Notification Protocol, if either the width
or the diameter of such containers exceeds 190 centimeters, the
Parties shall agree, within the framework of the Joint Compliance
and Inspection Commission, on procedures for the placement of
the neutron detector and the calibration source with respect to
such containers."
Article Three
Subparagraph 5(d) of Section IV of Annex 4 to the Inspection Protocol
shall be superseded by the following provision:
"(d) If, by making such measurements, inspectors are unable to confirm
that the contents of the container are not a long-range nuclear ALCM,
or that such a container does not conceal the presence of radiation,
they shall record their findings in the inspection report. A member
of the in-country escort shall, at the request of the inspectors, photograph
the contents of the container or the container, in accordance with the
procedures provided for in paragraph 27 of Section VI of this Protocol."
Article Four
This Agreement shall enter into force on the date of entry into force
of the Treaty, and shall remain in force as long as the Treaty remains
in force.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF the undersigned, being duly authorized by their
respective Governments, have signed this Agreement.
DONE at Geneva on November 3, 1994, in five copies, each in the English
and Russian languages, both texts being equally authentic.
FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA:
Steven Steiner
FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF BELARUS:
Andrey Sannikov
FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN:
Kairtay Zhanbatyrov
FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION:
Mikhail Strel'tsov
FOR THE GOVERNMENT OF UKRAINE:
Konstantin Hrishchenko
|